A study of risk factors for patients with Diabetic
foot ulcer
Ravichandran K.S.1
1Dr. K.S. Ravichandran, Associate Professor, Department
of General Surgery, Melmaruvathur Adhiparasakthi Institute of Medical Sciences,
Tamilnadu, India.
Corresponding
Author: Dr. K.S.Ravichandran, Associate
Professor, Department of General Surgery, Melmaruvathur Adhiparasakthi
Institute of Medical Sciences, Tamilnadu, India. E-mail: drksravichandranms@yahoo.com
Abstract
Background:
Peripheral neuropathy and peripheral
vascular diseases are the important causes of non-traumatic lower limb
amputation. The risk of amputation among diabetic patients increases by two to
four folds with the advancement of age and duration of diabetes.It has also
been proven by many longitudinal epidemiological studies that among diabetic
patients, the life time foot ulcer risk is about 25%, thereby accounting for
two thirds of all non-traumatic amputations. Clinical guidelines recommend that
all patients with diabetes should be screened annually to establish their risk
of foot ulceration. Aim: To ascertain
the risk factors leading to amputation for patients with diabetic foot ulcer. Materials and method: The present study
was conducted in the Department of General Surgery of Melmaruvathur Adhiparasakthi
institute of medical sciences. Melmaruvathur. For our study, we selected 200
patients admitted to the surgical ward with diagnosis of diabetic foot ulcer.
History of diabetic status of patient, whether patient was a undetected case or
a known diabetic, if known the duration of the disease, whether patient was on
regular or irregular treatment (diet/oral/drugs/insulin) were recorded. Lab
tests of each patient were conducted for hemoglobin, TLC, DLC, ESR, blood urea,
serum creatinine and blood sugar. All the cases were managed following
conservative and surgical approach. Results:
A total of 200 patients were present in the study group. The mean of the
subjects was 49.28 + 6.88 years. Out of 200 patients, 46 were females
and 154 were males. We observed that 54 patients were undetected at the time of
admission at hospital. Majority of patients (n=46) had duration of diabetes
from 5-10 years. 38 patients had duration of diabetes less than 4 years, 10
patients had duration of diabetes from 11-15 years. Most of the patients
present with more than one lesion. Only major lesion is considered here. Ulcer
was the major lesion seen in present series being present in 144 patients. Conclusion: We conclude that Routine
foot care should be available to every patient with diabetes ideally, but the
reality of most of these patient slack adequate knowledge and resources
resulting in the absence of such care.
Keywords:
Diabetes, Diabetic ulcer, Amputation, Foot
ulcer
Author Corrected: 20th February 2019 Accepted for Publication: 26th February 2019
Introduction
Few of the well-known complications of diabetes are
Peripheral neuropathy (PN) and peripheral vascular disease (PVD)[1] Patients
with PN and PVVD lack the conventional symptoms, but are still considered to be
at high risk for occurrence of foot complications [2-4]. PN and PVD are the
main causes of non-traumatic lower limb amputation [5]. The risk of ulceration
and amputation among diabetic patients increases by two to four folds with the
progression of age and duration of diabetes regardless of the type of diabetes
[6]. It has also been proven by many longitudinal epidemiological studies that
among diabetic patients, the life time foot ulcer risk is about 25%[7,8]. Thereby
accounting for two thirds of all non-traumatic amputations. Clinical guidelines
recommend that all patients with diabetes should be screened annually to
establish their risk of foot ulceration [8]. Diagnostic tests and physical
signs that detect peripheral neuropathy (biothesiometry, monofilaments and
absent ankle reflexes), and those that detect excessive plantar pressure (peak
plantar pressure and joint deformity) were all significantly associated with future
diabetic foot ulceration [9,10]. Hence the present study is planned to assess
the risk factors for patients suffering diabetic foot ulcer.
Materials and Method
Settings-The
present study was conducted in the Department of General Surgery of the Melmaruvathuradhiparasakthi
institute of medical sciences and research. It is a medical college, a tertiary
care center, catering to a population of around five lakh people, mostly rural
population.
Type
of study- It is a prospective study, analyzing the
different factors associated with diabetesleading to ulcers of the legs.
Ethical
clearance- The ethical clearance for the
protocol of study was obtained from the ethical committee of the institute.
Inclusion
criteria- For the study we selected 200 patients
admitted to the surgical ward with diagnosis of diabetic foot. The diagnosis was confirmed by detailed
history and clinical examination. An informed written consent was obtained from
each patient after explaining to them the procedure of the study.
Exclusion
criteria- Patients with end stage renal disease,
patients on regular dialysis. Patients with coronary heart disease, Patients
with history of tuberculosis or, leprosy, patients with unstable parameters,
were excluded from the study.
Statistical
methods- History of diabetic status of patient
was recorded. Whether the patient was an undetected case or a known diabetic, and,
if known, the duration of the disease, was noted whether patient was on regular
or irregular treatment (diet/oral/drugs/insulin) was also recorded. Lab tests
of each patient were conducted for hemoglobin, TLC, DLC, ESR, blood urea, serum
creatinine and blood sugar. Values were evaluated periodically Whenever
vascular insufficiency was detected in lower limbs, serum cholesterol ECG and
Doppler was done. In all the diabetic foot cases, pus was sent for culture and
sensitivity examination before starting antibiotics. All the details were
carefully recorded and analysed.
Surgical
methods- All the cases were managed following
conservative and surgical approaches, where ever necessary. Appropriate
Antibiotics and analgesics were prescribed for infection and inflammation.Proper
dressings were done.
Results
The statistical analysis of the data was done using
SPSS software for windows. The significance of the data was checked using
Chi-square test and Student’s t-test. A p-value<0.05 was predetermined to be
statistical significant. The mean of the subjects was 49.28 + 6.88
years. Out of 200, 46 were females and 154 were males. Table 1 shows the frequency of patients with different duration of
diabetes. We observed that 54 patients were undetected at the time of admission
at hospital. Majority of patients (n=92) had duration of diabetes from 5-10
years. 38 patients had duration of diabetes less than 4 years, 10 patients had
duration of diabetes from 11-15 years. Only 2 patients in the group had diabetes
from 21-25 years.
Table-1: Frequency
of patients with different duration of diabetes
Duration of diabetes |
Number of patients |
Undetected |
54 |
<4
years |
38 |
5-10
years |
92 |
11-15
years |
10 |
16-20
years |
4 |
21-25
years |
2 |
Total |
200 |
Table-2: Incidence of different type
of lesions in study group
Type of lesion on foot |
No. of cases |
Gangrene |
58 |
Cellulitis |
94 |
Abscess |
32 |
Ulcer |
144 |
Table-
2 shows the incidence of different type
of lesions in study group. The different types of lesions included cellulitis,
abscess, ulcer and gangrene. Most of the patients present with more than one
lesion. Only major lesion is considered here. Ulcer was the major lesion seen
in present series being present in 144 patients. While abscess seen in 32
patients, was the least common lesion.
Discussion
Diabetes
mellitus- Diabetes mellitus is a worldwide
disease.It affects all ages, It affects both male and female equally. Almost
all races are affected by diabetes. Diabetes mellitus has reached epidemic
properties worldwide as we enter the new millennium. The world health organization
has commented there is “an apparent epidemic over the next decade the projected
number will exceed 200 million, Diabetes affects the entire body, from head to
toe. Diabetic neuropathy, Diabetic nephropathy, Diabetic retinopathy, and
coronary ischaemia are some of the common problems associated with diabetes. However,
the most common one is foot ulcer. Diabetic foot is a serious complication of
diabetes mellitus when compared with people without diabetes. Foot ulcers are
significant complications of diabetes mellitus and often precede lower
extremity amputation. Recurrence of the foot infection was common among India
diabetic patients about 52%. 6 Infection and gangrene of the lower extremities
are the most common lesions requiring hospitalization in diabetes and are a
major cause of morbidity [4].
In the present study, we observed that diabetic foot
ulcer was most common in the patients having diabetes since 8-10 years. Patients
with longstanding diabetes will definitely develop foot ulcers at some point of
time. Also, the diabetic foot ulcer was most common lesion observed in
patients. Few patients had callus, corn foot, abscess, eczema etc. The results
were compared with previous studies and were found to be consistent. Shahbazian
H et al assessed diabetic foot ulcer risk factors according to International
Working Group on the Diabetic Foot (IWGDF) consensus. Based on the IWGDF criteria, they divided all
the referral patients into four study groups; patients without neuropathy, patients
with neuropathy, patients with vascular disease associated neuropathy and
patients with foot ulcer. 53.8 years was the mean age of the patients in their
study group. They analyzed a total of 400 patients out of which 269 were
females, while the remaining 161 were males. Disturbance in the sense of
vibration was observed in 23 percent of the patients in their study, while fall
in sensitivity to monofilaments was seen in 26 percent of the patients. In 17
percent of the patients, they observed a decrease in pain sensation. In 6
percent of the patients, they observed abnormality in ankle brachial index
(ABI). Past history of prior ulcer was seen in 7 percent of the patients of
their study. From the results, they concluded that advancing age along with diabetes
duration and diabetic retinopathy increases the risk for the development of
diabetic ulcer [11].
In another study conducted by Wu L et al, the
authors determined the prevalence of various risk factors responsible for
occurrence of diabetic foot in patients with diabetes. They retrospectively
evaluated a total of 296 patients who were admitted to the tertiary hospital
because of diabetes. A questionnaire was framed and was made to be filled by
all the patients. They also assessed their foot along with presence of absence
of peripheral sensory neuropathy (PSN) and peripheral arterial disease (PVD).
They observed foot deformity in 124 patients with the most prevalent
abnormality being hallux valgus, which was observed in 65 percent of the
patients of their study. From the results, they concluded that risk factors for foot ulceration and lack of
fool care knowledge was rather common in a hospital-based diabetic population,
emphasizing the importance of implementing simple and affordable screening
tools and methods to identify high-risk patients and providing foot care
education for them [11,12].
In another study conducted by Sarinnapakorn V et al,
the authors evaluated the overall prevalence of diabetic foot ulcers. From the
results, they concluded that diabetic patients are at intermediate for the
development of diabetic foot ulcer. They also stressed that for the
classification of the diabetic patients on the basis of risk factors, it is
necessary to classify patients. Nyamu PN et al, in another study, evaluated the
prevalence rate of patients with diabetic foot ulcers and the risk factors.
They evaluated a total of 1788 diabetic patients and observed that in
approximately four to five percent of the patients had diabetic foot ulcer.
They observed presence of diabetic foot ulcer in patients with comparatively
longer duration of diabetes. From the results, they concluded that the risk
factors of diabetic foot ulcers were poor glycemic control, diastolic
hypertension, dyslipidaemia, infection and poor self-care [13,14].
In our study of 200 patients,we find majority of the
patients with ulcers belong to the chronic diabetes group. The pathological
changes in the nervous system lead to sensory impairment and peripheral
neuropathy. Similarly, the changes in the blood vessel walls lead to narrowing
of the lumen and gradual ischaemia develops. These changes are more visible in
the lower limbs. Diastolic hypertension is seen in many of the patients with
diabetic foot ulcers. Peripheral neuropathy was seen in more than 80 percent of
the study group. Folic acid deficiency and Vitamin B12 deficiency have been
documented in many studies. In our study, 68 percent were having sub optimal
levels of B12. Most of our population are not using shoes. In our study, 56
percent were using normal open type footwear. The recurrence rate of ulcer was
high among them, when compared to those using shoes.
Another important finding was that diabetic persons
with chronic smoking, tend to come with recurrent ulcers. inspite of adequate
glycemic control. It may be well explained by the vascular ischaemia of the
extremities. We have also noted, Iron deficiency anaemia was seen in 86
patientsand Hypoproteinemia seen in 36 patients.Ulcer healing was very much
delayed in these patients with anaemia and hypoproteinemia. Patients on regular
insulin medication were less affected with leg ulcers, when compared with
patients on oral hypoglycemic agents. Patients on OHA develop diabetic foot
ulcer earlier than those on Insulin,
Conclusion
Diabetic foot ulcer is a rapidly increasing entity.
In our study, the important risk factors were found to be poor glycemic
control,peripheral neuropathy, and poor podiatric care. The same has been
evaluated in many publications in the past.
Within the limitations of present study, we conclude
that Routine foot care should be available to every patient with diabetes.
Adequate glycemic control to be achieved with insulin, All health care facilities
should have a podiatric wing and trained healthcare workers.
References
How to cite this article?
Ravichandran K.S. A study of risk factors for patients with Diabetic foot ulcer. Surgical Update: Int J surg Orthopedics. 2019; 5(1):41-45.doi:10.17511/ ijoso.2019.i1.07.