Demographic study
of hemorrhoid with analysis of risk factors
Malviya V.K.1, Diwan S.2,
Sainia T.K.3, Apte A.4
1Dr. Vikas Kumar Malviya, Assistant Professor, 2Dr. Shivam
Diwan, Post Graduate Student First year, 3Dr. Tarun Kumar Sainia, Associate
Professor, 4Dr. Ashwin Apte, Professor, all authors are affiliated
with Department of General Surgery, L.N. Medical College Bhopal, India.
Corresponding Author: Dr. Shivam Diwan, General Surgery, RSO 1st
Year, PostGraduate Student First year Department of General Surgery, L.N.
Medical College Bhopal, India. E-mail: shivamdiwan7491@gmail.com
Abstract
Background: Hemorrhoids are the most prevalent benign
anorectal disorder diagnosed in clinical practice. Risk factors commonly associated with hemorrhoidal disease include low
fiber diet, chronic constipation & diarrhea, straining during defecation,
pregnancy, sedentary lifestyle, obesity etc. Treatment of symptomatic
first-degree, second degree and early third-degree hemorrhoids includes banding
and sclerotherapy. Patients with fourth-degree or large third-degree
hemorrhoids should be referred for hemorrhoidectomy surgery. Methods: This retrospective study was
conducted in the department of surgery in J.K. Hospital Bhopal. 430 adult
patients with diagnosis of hemorrhoids, admitted in surgery ward were included
in this study. All the relevant details were obtained from medical record
department with all demographic details. Results: Most of the patients (46%)
belongs to the younger age (20-40 years). 69% were male patients and 31% were
female patients. Patients with higher socioeconomic status were most commonly
affected group (37.2%) with hemorrhoids. Commonest symptoms was Bleeding per
rectum. In the
present study, risk factors for hemorrhoids were low fiber diet, mixed diet,
poor hydration, chronic constipation or diarrhea, straining during the
defecation, low physical activity and obesity. Sclerotherapy (11.1%) and rubber band ligation (4.1%) were non
operative treatment. Operative
procedures performed in the present study were open hemorrhoidectomy (81.4%)
and stapled hemorrhoidopexy (3.2%). Conclusion: This demographic
study of hemorrhoidal disease in this region can guide us to better understand
the trends of this disease which is most commonly encountered in our society.This useful information may aid in the assessment and
definitive care of these patients with hemorrhoids.
Keywords: Haemorrhoids; Demographic study;
Risk factor
Author Corrected: 27th January 2019 Accepted for Publication: 30th January 2019
Introduction
Hemorrhoids
or piles are bundles of vascular structure that contain enlarged blood vessels present within elastic fibers, smooth
muscles and connective tissue of anus and anal canal. Usually these hemorrhoids
work as venous cushions in normal individual and are the common cause of anal
pathology [1]. These venous cushions help in control of stool defecation, but
whenever there is a swelling or inflammation in these cushions, these become a
pathologically a disease known as hemorrhoids. Hemorrhoid present as swelling,
itching, pain during defecations and bleeding per rectum.
Hemorrhoids are the
most common benign anorectal disorder diagnosed in clinical practice and
constitute about 50% of colorectal investigations [2]. Hemorrhoids are so much
common in India that every perianal disease is termed as hemorrhoid by most of
the patients. Although hemorrhoids are so common, only few patients seek
medical treatment due to embarrassment. Hemorrhoids are more common in the
adult population. Men are more frequently affected in comparison to women [3].
Hemorrhoids are
categorized as internal and external depending on location. Pectinate or
dentate line that divides upper two thirds and lower one third of the anus is
the demarcation line between external and internal hemorrhoids. External
hemorrhoids are covered by skin and located below this line. Internal
hemorrhoids are covered by mucosa and are located above the pectinate line.
Internal hemorrhoids are true hemorrhoid with various degrees depending upon
extent of protrusion out of anal canal and are located at 3, 7 and 11 o’ clock
position.
Internal
hemorrhoids are generally classified into first, second, third and fourth
degree according to the classification published by Banov et al [4].First
degree hemorrhoids don't protrude out of the anal canal and may present as
bleeding per rectum and discomfort. Second degree
hemorrhoids protrude with defecation and retract on their own and the
patient may present as obvious swelling that disappears spontaneously and
rapidly after defecation. Third-degree
hemorrhoids protrude and usually require manual replacement. Fourth degree hemorrhoids protrude all the time and
cannot be reduced manually and present as persistent prolapsed pile.
Risk
factors commonly associated with hemorrhoidal disease include low fiber diet,
chronic constipation, chronic diarrhea, chronic straining during defecation,
pregnancy, sedentary lifestyle, habit of postponing the bowel movements,
obesity and spinal cord injuries etc.
Prevention is
better than cure in cases of the hemorrhoids.
Several treatment options are available for patients with hemorrhoid, who do
not respond to conservative medical management [5-8].Treatment
guidelines are available from the American College of Gastroenterology (ACG)
[9]. Treatment guidelines of American College of
Gastroenterology (ACG) recommend that patients with symptomatic first- to
third-degree hemorrhoids initially be treated with increased fiber and adequate
fluid intake and can be managed by various office procedures, including
banding, sclerotherapy, and infrared coagulation and ligation [9]. Patients
with fourth-degree or large third-degree hemorrhoids should be referred for
hemorrhoidectomy surgery if they are refractory to or unable to tolerate office
procedures [9]. Complications of untreated symptomatic hemorrhoid may include
thrombosis, secondary infection, ulceration, abscess, and incontinence.
There is no published epidemiological study
on hemorrhoidal diseases which categorized the risk factors in this region. The
aim of this retrospective study is to compile the demographic data in patients
with hemorrhoid and assess the risk factors associated with this disease.
Methods
Place of study: Department of Surgery, J.K. Hospital
associated with L.N. Medical College Bhopal (M.P.).
Type of study: Retrospective study
Sampling Method: Consecutive
Sample collection: Data were collected from medical record
department. 430 adult patients with diagnosis of hemorrhoids, fulfilling all
the inclusion criteria were included in this study. All the relevant details
were obtained from medical record department with all demographic details. Data
were tabulated using detailed proforma.
Following details of patients were recorded like age, sex, socioeconomic
status, symptoms and risk factors. In all case records of admitted patients
with hemorrhoids, final diagnosis was made on the basis of detailed history,
clinical & digital per rectal examination and proctoscopy. External examination with inspection of the
anal and perianal region was done to see external sentinel piles, prolapsed
internal piles and fissure or perianal ulceration. On digital per rectal
examination were usually done to rule out any pathology like rectal carcinoma,
rectal polyp, hypertrophied anal papilla, thrombosed internal piles etc. The
anal sphincter tone was also assessed.Proctoscopy was usually done in each case
to see the internal hemorrhoids with their location and to rule out any pathology.
Conservative management was preferred in first, second
and some third degree hemorrhoid. Patients with fourth degree or large third-degree
hemorrhoids were treated by open hemorrhoidectomy surgery or stapled
hemorrhoidopexy. All the relevant collected data was compiled on master chart.
Inclusion criteria: Patients with hemorrhoid of age group 20 to
80 years who were admitted in surgery ward were included in the study
ExclusionCriteria: Patients with piles secondary to anorectal
tumor, pregnant female patients and patients less than 20 years of age were
excluded from study
Statistical Methods: Results were shown in tables, comparing their
numbers and percentages by scientific calculator and standard appropriate
statistical formula.
EthicalPermission: Yes
Results
The aim of this study was to analyze statistics in
patients with hemorrhoids to explain the demographic details and risk factors
associated with hemorrhoids. Records of patients with hemorrhoids who were
admitted in surgical wards were obtained from medical record department and
after analysis the data following observations and results were obtained.
Table-1: Age wise
distribution
Age
group (years) |
Total
admission |
% |
20-40 |
198 |
46.0% |
41-60 |
136 |
31.6% |
61-80 |
96 |
22.3% |
|
430 |
|
Age
– Highest number of patients belongs to the young age group of 20-40 years.
Table-2: Sex Wise
Distribution
|
Total
admission |
% |
Male |
297 |
69% |
Female |
133 |
31% |
|
430 |
|
Sex
– The male to female ratio was 2.2:1. Out of total admission of 430, 69% were
male patients and 31% were female patients.
Table-3: Socioeconomic
status wise distribution
|
Total
admission |
% |
Lower |
142 |
33.0% |
Middle |
128 |
29.7% |
Upper |
160 |
37.2% |
Total |
430 |
|
Patients
with higher socioeconomic status were most commonly affected group (37.2%) with
hemorrhoids.
Table-4: Symptoms
Complaints
|
Number
of patients |
% |
·
Bleeding per rectum |
290 |
67.5% |
·
Pain during defecation |
230 |
53.5% |
·
Pruritus ani |
160 |
37.2% |
·
Discharge |
112 |
26.0% |
·
Prolapsed swelling |
108 |
25.1% |
·
Soiling |
40 |
9.3% |
Most common symptoms were bleeding per rectum (67.5%).
Other symptoms were pain during defecation (53.5%), pruritus ani (37.2%),
discharge (26.0%), prolapsed swelling (25.1%) and soiling (9.3%)
Table-5: Common Risk Factors for hemorrhoids
|
|
Number
of patients |
% |
Dietary habits |
Low fiber diet |
318 |
73.9% |
|
Mixed diet |
289 |
67.2% |
|
Poor hydration |
146 |
34% |
Bowel habits |
Chronic constipation or diarrhea |
275 |
64% |
Straining during
defecation |
253 |
58.8% |
|
Amount of physical activity |
Low physical activity |
150 |
34.9% |
Obesity |
177 |
41.1% |
Risk factors commonly
associated with hemorrhoidal disease include low fiber diet, chronic
constipation, chronic diarrhea, chronic straining during defecation, pregnancy,
sedentary lifestyle, habit of postponing the bowel movements, obesity and
spinal cord injuries etc.
Table-6: Types of hemorrhoids present
|
Number of patients |
% |
|
External hemorrhoid |
68 |
15.8% |
|
Internal hemorrhoid |
First degree |
11 |
2.5% |
Second degree |
55 |
12.7% |
|
Third degree |
150 |
34.8% |
|
Fourth degree |
146 |
33.9% |
Diagnosis
was based on external, digital per rectal examinations and proctoscopy; following
findings were obtained.
Table-7:Management of hemorrhoids
|
Procedure |
|
|
|
Conservative management |
Rubber band ligation |
18 |
4.1% |
15.3% |
Sclerotherapy |
48 |
11.1% |
||
Operative management |
Open hemorrhoidectomy |
350 |
81.4% |
84.6% |
Stapled hemorrhoidopexy |
14 |
3.2% |
Management
– Non-operative
procedures were reserved for first degree, second-degree and early third degree
hemorrhoids and are usually carried out on outpatient basis (15.3%). Patients with fourth degree or large
third-degree hemorrhoids were treated by open hemorrhoidectomy surgery or
stapled hemorrhoidopexy (84.6%).
Discussion
Hemorrhoids
are common anorectal disease that affects about most of the population by the
age of 50 years.Age wise distribution analysis of the data
reveals that most
common age group affected with hemorrhoids in our study was middle age group
(41-60 years). It was almost similar to the study conducted by Ravindranath GG
et al and Ali SA et al where most common age group was below 40 years [10, 11].
This was in contrary with studies of Khan et al and Johanson et al [3, 12].
Sex wise distribution of hemorrhoids in our study reveals
that the male to female ratio was 2.2:1. Out of total admission of 430, 69%
were male patients and 31% were female patients. This may be due to a
greater likelihood of men seeking treatment for their hemorrhoids and
embarrassment felt by women to consult for anorectal problems. A
male predominance (66.7%)
compared to the females (33.3%) suggested by Ravindranath GG et al [10]. A 55%
male predominance was also seen in a study by Ali SAet al [11].
Socioeconomic status had a significant effect on patients
with hemorrhoids and our study showed that patients with higher socioeconomic
status were most commonly affected group (37.2%) with hemorrhoids. According to Lohsiriwat V in
a study, whites and higher socioeconomic status individuals were affected more
frequently than blacks and those of lower socioeconomic status [13]. This
association of hemorrhoid to higher socioeconomic status may be due to more
prevalence of constipation due to dietary habits and lack of physical activity
in this group. Also the patients with higher socioeconomic status usually have
health seeking behavior.
The study of symptoms present in patients with
hemorrhoids revealed that most of the patients had more than one complaint. The most common
symptoms of hemorrhoids in the present study is bleeding per rectum (67.5%)
followed by pain during defecation (53.5%), pruritus ani (37.2%), discharge
(26%), prolapsed swelling (25.1%) and soiling (9.3%). Similar findings were
suggested by Ali SA et al [11]. But this data was contradictory to Nikooiyan et
al in a study where the most common symptoms was pruritus (45.8%); other
symptoms observed by him were discharge (41.6%) and the anal pain (22.5%)[2].
Risk factors evaluation in our study presents that the pathogenesis of
hemorrhoids is not completely clear, but as stated by Kann et al, “all
etiologic and risk factors work toward stretching and slippage of the
hemorrhoidal tissue” [14].As the supporting tissue of the anal cushions
weakens, downward displacement of the cushions can occur, causing venous
dilation and prolapse [15, 16]. In the present study, risk factors for hemorrhoids were low fiber diet,
mixed diet, poor hydration, chronic constipation or diarrhea, straining during
the defecation, low physical activity and obesity.
Constipation
and prolonged straining are the main risk factor to cause hemorrhoids in
present study.Hard stool and increased intra-abdominal pressure could cause
obstruction of venous return, resulting in engorgement of the hemorrhoidal
plexus which leads to development of hemorrhoid [17]. Defecation of hard fecal
material increases shearing force on the anal cushions. However, recent
evidence questions the importance of constipation in the development of this
common disorder [18]. Many investigators have failed to demonstrate any
significant association between hemorrhoids and constipation, whereas some
reports suggested that diarrhea is a risk factor for the development of
hemorrhoids [12].
Low fiber intake,
high intake of spicy and non-vegetarian mixed diet and poor hydration were
found to be the risk factors of hemorrhoids in the present study. Increase
dietary intake of fiber, vegetarian non spicy diet and increased hydration can
improve and prevent the hemorrhoid by reducing the constipation which is a
known risk factor for development of hemorrhoids. According to Anne
F. Peery et al high grain fiber intake was associated with a reduced
risk [19].
Sedentary life
style, obesity and low physical activity was also one of the risk factors of
hemorrhoids, which was corroborated by Khan et al in his study [3]. But
according to Anne
F. Peery et al, sedentary behavior was associated with a reduced
risk, but not physical activity [19]. Neither being overweight nor obese was
associated with the presence of hemorrhoids.
In our study, the analysis of types of hemorrhoids
present was seen and diagnosis was made after doing examination of the patient.
In present study,
most of the admitted patients were related to external hemorrhoid, third and
fourth degree internal hemorrhoids, which were operated. As most of the
patients, with first and second degree were usually treated in outdoor with
conservative treatment, so these cases were found to be less in the present
study. In few cases they were admitted for conservative treatment and
procedures like sclerotherapy and rubber band ligation in ward.
According to a
study by Stefan Riss et al, out of the 976 participants, 380 patients (38.93%)
suffered from hemorrhoids. In 277 patients (72.89%), hemorrhoids were
classified as grade I, in 70 patients (18.42%) as grade II, in 31 patients
(8.16%) as grade III, and in 2 patients (0.53%) as grade IV [20].
There were two methods of management incorporated in our
study based on the degree of hemorrhoid present. Two non-operative procedures
were reserved for first-degree, second-degree hemorrhoids and early third
degree hemorrhoids, these cases were treated on outpatient basis and in some
cases of admitted patients.
Sclerotherapy was most common non operative treatment, which were
performed in 48 patients (11.1%) by injecting chemical agents like 5% phenol in oil or
hypertonic salt solution into the sub mucosa to induce the fibrosis [21].
Rubber band ligation was performed in selected patients (4.1%) with third-degree
hemorrhoids. Ligation of the hemorrhoidal tissue with a rubber band causes
ischemic necrosis and scarring, leading to fixation of the connective tissue to
the rectal wall. RBL can be safely performed in one or more than one place in a
single session [22].
Operative treatment were usually indicated when the conservative measures
have failed with complication. Most common procedure performed in the present
study was open hemorrhoidectomy (81.4%). Excisional hemorrhoidectomy
is the most effective treatment for hemorrhoids with the lowest rate of
recurrence compared to other modalities [23].
Stapled
hemorrhoidopexy was performed in only 14 patients (3.2%) due to high cost of
stapler. Stapled hemorrhoidopexy has been introduced since 1998[24]. A circular
stapling device is used to excise a ring of redundant rectal mucosa proximal to
hemorrhoids and resuspend the hemorrhoids back within the anal canal. A recent
meta-analysis comparing surgical outcomes between stapled hemorrhoidopexyand
hemorrhoidectomy, showed that stapled hemorrhoidopexywas associated with less
pain, earlier return of bowel function, shorter hospital stay, earlier return
to normal activities, and better wound healing, as well as higher degree of
patient satisfaction[25].
Conclusion
Symptomatic
Hemorrhoids are one of the common benign diseases usually found in patients
with risk factors like chronic constipation, improper dietary habits, lack of
physical activity and obesity.So the patients should be educated to change his
dietary habits, to increase his daily physical activity and to prevent the
constipation.
Contribution from authors
· Dr Vikas Kumar Malviya formulated the aims & objectives with study
design.
· Dr Tarun Kumar Sainia contributed to the preparation of the manuscript
and Data analysis.
· Dr Shivam Diwan helped in data collection from medical record
department.
· Dr Ashwin Apte supervised and guided for study
What this study add to existing knowledge: This
demographic study of hemorrhoidal disease in this region can guide us to better
understanding of the trends of this disease, which is most commonly encountered
in our society. This useful information may aid
in the assessment and definitive care of these patients with hemorrhoids.
Conflict of Interest: None declared.
Funding: Nil
Permission from IRB: Yes
References
How to cite this article?
Malviya V.K, Diwan S, Sainia T.K, Apte A. Demographic study of hemorrhoid with analysis of risk factors. Surgical Update: Int J surg Orthopedics.2019;5(1):7-13.doi:10.17511/ ijoso.2019.i1.02.